Geoffrey is actually killed into the a biking collision in 1186 and Constance married (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, cuatro th Earl from Chester, into the 3 rd February 1188, during the a marriage set up of the Queen Henry 11. It relationships deteriorated and you may Ranulph imprisoned Constance in the 1196. Rebellions was indeed stimulated across the Brittany on her and you can Ranulph put-out their own for the 1198. Back to Brittany, Constance had their unique wedding annulled and later within the 1198, she took Guy de Tours just like the their own ‘second’ husband.
Constance died old 40, (possibly off leprosy, maybe following childbirth so you can twin girls) for the 5 th Sep 1201 during the Nantes
Even though this was not a beneficial consanguineous relationship but one of attraction, people earliest-studies relationship could have made relationships ranging from Constance and you may any one of John’s brothers hopeless instead of a beneficial dispensation –– and that considering the party’s review would have was required to come from the fresh pope themselves
The theory one to Constance had an affair which have John following the loss of Geoffrey and you will prior to John’s relationships so you’re able to Isabella out-of Gloucester inside the 1189, and therefore she try mother so you can Joanna is really controversial and you may has provoked far discussion in this genealogical sectors.
One to opinion regarding a great genealogist claims one ‘the brand new record ‘The Plantagenet Connection’ has actually published an ahnentafel away from E Plantagenet, wife away from Henry V11, that gives Joanna’s mom’s identity while the Constance (maybe misnamed Clemence?), Duchess regarding Brittany. This is actually the Constance who was John’s sis-in-laws! As a result of the really-identified animosity between John and Constance along with her very own tries to drive their own son Arthur’s interests so far as the fresh throne regarding England is actually alarmed (so we all recognize how disastrously that turned-out!), I truly discover the advised relationships a small tough to take. The new Constance one to history portrays cannot hit me while the for the whom John can potentially coerce on the bed.’
‘ A theory who pick Joanna’s mom because Constance does not account for a very important point in canon law. That would indicate that particular shadow of one’s number need to surely have come right down to united states, if it involved the fresh new obtain they, the new deliberations, and/or genuine dispensation in itself. As much as i have always been aware, absolutely nothing of kind can be obtained.’
From the simply that have sex with John, not to mention influence your a child, Constance would have oriented a first-studies dating away from attraction with all of John’s siblings –– in addition to John’s cousin Geoffrey
My thoughts for just what it’s really worth, would be the fact had Constance become mom from Joanna she would positively provides put their unique right up within her domestic along with her title could be as well known as Constance’s other students of the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Housemaid regarding Brittany, Matilda/Maud regarding Brittany and you may Arthur).
Agatha came into this world in the 1168 inside Chartley Palace, Staffordshire. It’s well known one to she was a domme away from John and some family members woods promote their, regardless of if solitary, as the mother out-of Joanna. Very genealogists however believe it is only conjecture one to she is Joanna’s mother while the no research otherwise facts can be found showing this.
You to resource seem to provided is Sir William Dugdale, regarding the Baronage away from The united kingdomt (1675-6). According to him their supply to be Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s efforts are an increased edition out-of H Lloyd’s interpretation from ‘This new Historie away from Cambria’ of the several th century Saint Caradoc from Llancarfan. Another type of supply, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ because of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 as well as names Agatha de- Ferrers, child away from Robert de- Ferrers, last Earl away from derby, since Joanna’s mother.
Regardless of if she can’t be entirely overlooked once the an applicant to have mommy away from Joanna, surely there would be specific trace regarding their when you look at the a chronicle or other historic naiset TЕЎekki: lta etsivГ¤t amerikkalaista miestГ¤ source, if the she got in fact been mom of the partner off this new Prince out of North Wales.